Saturday, 9 February 2008

Asian interdependence and the US recession

After writing the previous "Has China's growth peaked" I hinted at the interdependence of Asian countries and their subsequent relationship with the US and EU.

When one looks at the raw numbers, e.g. the % of exports to the US it might not appear to be that high. However, when one takes its account the exports of intermediate goods to other Asian countries that are then exported to the US and EU you can see that the problem goes a lot deeper. There are many academic papers that are looking at production networks and fragmentation in Asia and I may even have written one of two of them.

This is the important quote with numbers. Intuitively they appear to be about right.

Asian exports to the US appear to be just 18 per cent. But, the real amount, including all the “goods in process”, might be more than 30 per cent, he calculates.


I do not believe the de-coupling story. This is one of those pre-recession stories of hope that "the world has changed" when it hasn't. A US recesission will bite hard let there be no doubt.

Asia economies hope for happy divorce [FT]

Asia’s export-dependent economies are hoping that decoupling – the notion that the rest of the world can grow even with the US in recession – will hold true.

There have been signs. Over the past year, Japanese shipments to China have risen by 15 per cent, to Europe and other Asian nations by 11.5 per cent, and to the “rest of world”, including the oil-flush Middle East, by 25 per cent.

Still, exports to the US have been fading fast, down 1.7 per cent on the year, and because Japan’s eagerly awaited recovery in domestic demand has never materialised, its economy has been running on only one (export-led) engine. This fiscal year its economy is expected to grow by what analysts describe as a disappointing 1.3 per cent.

Peter Morgan, chief economist for Asia Pacific at HSBC, says that one of the chinks in decoupling’s armour is Europe.

The region has been happily sucking in Asian imports thanks to its strong currency and reasonably good economic performance. But as Asian currencies appreciate, against the euro as well as the dollar, and European economies slow, that will change. “That is going to take away one of the legs of the stool,” he says.

Exports to the Middle East, which accounts for a fairly modest but rapidly growing portion of Asian exports, should hold up assuming demand for oil stays firm. But the foundations of intra-Asian trade, on which much of the argument about export diversification rests, could be more rickety than they appear.

One thing to remember is that a lot of exports to China are just passing through,” says Mr Morgan, referring to China’s role as an assembly plant for Asian components.

Asian exports to the US appear to be just 18 per cent. But, the real amount, including all the “goods in process”, might be more than 30 per cent, he calculates.

Thailand is a good example. Recent economic growth has been powered primarily by exports, about 12.5 per cent of which went directly to the US last year, down from about 20 per cent when the previous US recession struck in 2001.

Yet Thailand is not as insulated as this might suggest. Sethaput Suthiwart-Narueput, chief economist at SCB Securities, says Bangkok remains vulnerable to a US slowdown since most of its exports to China – about 9.5 per cent of total shipments, up from 4.4 per cent in 2001 – are components used to make goods bound for the US.

The picture is not black and white and decoupling is not an “either/or phenomenon”, says Paul Sheard, global chief economist at Lehman Brothers. Asia emerged relatively unscathed from the 1991 US recession but was much harder hit by the “tech recession” of 2001. Similarly, this time, depending on the precise nature of any downturn, commodity-rich Australia, Indonesia and Malaysia might fare better than, say, countries specialising in electronics, such as Taiwan or South Korea.

Indonesia, for example, has already noticed its non-oil and gas exports slowing to the US. Mari Pangestu, trade minister, told the Financial Times: “Our strategy now is to diversify markets and diversify products. We think the growth market is still Asia, although if the US does fall into recession it will have an impact on the high-growth economies.”

The US remains India’s largest export market, reducing the country’s chances of surviving a US downturn unscathed. The Reserve Bank of India says it has already seen a slowdown in the crucial software and services exports.

By contrast, Australia’s reliance on US exports has substantially diminished. Tim Harcourt, chief economist at the Australian Trade Commission, points out that the US share of Australia’s exports has fallen from 10 per cent to just 6 per cent as “Australia has benefited from the global economy firing on more cylinders than usual.”

China and the health of its economy could be a key factor for many others in Asia. If China’s role as the world’s assembly plant is vulnerable to a US downturn, its infrastructure-led demand is less so. Barring the truly unexpected, even a US recession is not likely to push Chinese growth much below 9 per cent, against 11.4 per cent last year.

Depending on the components of that growth, there could be more demand for, say, raw materials and construction equipment and less for components and factory machinery.

That could slow, but not throttle, growth in some Asian economies. For example, both Singapore and Malaysia have seen a slowdown in their biggest export category, electronics.

But, according to Kit Wei Zheng, a Citigroup economist, Singapore is unlikely to suffer as big a slump as in 2001 because it has diversified into other export areas, including pharmaceuticals. Likewise, Malaysia is partly cushioned by the global demand for palm oil.

Diversification will only go so far, however, particularly if US consumption nosedives, says Mr Sheard. “Asia, centred on China, has become even more interlinked into the global economy, the driving impetus of which has been the US,” he said. It is hard to be global and decoupled at the same time.


Exactly.

.

3 comments:

metin2gogo said...

air jordan 4 retro mars white red cheap on sale 65

air jordan 4 retro black cement red cheap on sale 55

air jordan 4 retro black tour yellow cheap on sale 66

air jordan 4 retro black cat cheap on sale 63

air jordan 4 retro cool grey cheap on sale 59

air jordan 4 retro tour yellow grey cheap on sale 67

air jordan 4 retro white black cement cheap on sale 56

air jordan 4 retro white classic green cheap on sale 58

air jordan 4 retro white midnight navy cheap on sale 57

air jordan 4 retro white military blue cheap on sale 68

air jordan 4 retro white tour yellow cheap on sale 64

air jordan 4 19 countdown package cheap on sale 367

air jordan 5 00 retro white metallic silver cheap on sale 71

air jordan 5 00 retro white royal maize cheap on sale 70

air jordan 5 re retro black silver red cheap on sale 80

air jordan 5 retro army olive orange cheap on sale 76

air jordan 5 retro black university blue cheap on sale 72

air jordan 5 retro burgundy graphite cheap on sale 78

metin2gogo said...

air jordan 5 retro dmp raging bull cheap on sale 81

air jordan 5 retro silver green bean cheap on sale 73

air jordan 5 retro silver pink cheap on sale 75

air jordan 5 retro white black red cheap on sale 69

air jordan 5 retro white dark army cheap on sale 82

air jordan 5 retro white emerald grape cheap on sale 74

air jordan 5 retro white fire red black cheap on sale 77

air jordan 5 retro white olive laser cheap on sale 79

air jordan 6 retro black infared cheap on sale 83

air jordan 6 retro charity navy red cheap on sale 87

air jordan 6 retro olympic 2000 cheap on sale 84

air jordan 6 retro olympic 2008 cheap on sale 86

air jordan 6 retro oreo white black cheap on sale 88

air jordan 6 retro pistons black red blue cheap on sale 89

air jordan 6 retro white midnight navy cheap on sale 85

air jordan 6 17 countdown package cheap on sale 372

air jordan 7 retro black chambray cheap on sale 93

air jordan 7 retro black citrus cheap on sale 97

metin2gogo said...

air jordan 7 retro black red cheap on sale 90

air jordan 7 retro dmp bulls magic cheap on sale 98

air jordan 7 retro olympic 2004 cheap on sale 92

air jordan 7 retro pearl white pacific blue cheap on sale 94

air jordan 7 retro white cardinal red cheap on sale 95

air jordan 7 retro white french blue cheap on sale 91

air jordan 7 retro white grey purple cheap on sale 96

air jordan 7 16 countdown package cheap on sale 368

air jordan 8 retro q rich white blue orange cheap on sale 107

air jordan 8 retro sugar ray black green cheap on sale 106

air jordan 8 retro black aqua cheap on sale 101

air jordan 8 retro black chrome cheap on sale 100

air jordan 8 retro black varsity red cheap on sale 105

air jordan 8 retro white aqua cheap on sale 102

air jordan 8 retro white black red cheap on sale 99

air jordan 8 retro white orange silver cheap on sale 103

air jordan 8 15 countdown package cheap on sale 365

air jordan 9 original black red cheap on sale 150