Wednesday, 15 August 2007

"Graft", "Confucianism" and Chinese business

Whilst the fallout from the Mattel recall still reverberates it is worth reminding ourselves about the endemic culture of corruption that pervades Chinese business.

In many senses this is cultural and one should not expect Western values to be so quickly absorbed into mainstream business. With Confucianism putting loyalty to friends first it is no surprise to see an element of "capture" taking place within firms. It is fascinating to read how businesses are being advised to hire geographically dispersed workers to prevent such behaviour.

Dirty dealing [Economist]
THE announcement on July 26th that Chen Liangyu is to be prosecuted for corruption came as little surprise. The former chief of the Communist Party in Shanghai had been the subject of a well-publicised investigation since a 3 billion yuan ($390m) hole was found in the city's pension fund last year. Mr Chen's is the highest-profile corruption case for a decade, and although his prosecution is suspected of having political motivations too, it is a signal that the government is serious about clamping down on corruption.

This week several top media officials in Guangzhou were arrested for allegedly selling advertising slots privately. The stockmarket has also suffered from a rash of dodgy dealing, with 11 firms blacklisted and almost 300 people penalised in the past six months for activities including publishing fake company reports and false auditing. Every week, it seems, the local press has stories about people who have illicitly squirrelled away huge sums.

The fact that these crimes are now reported is itself a step forward. As in many countries the mentality of graft is deeply ingrained in China. But Chinese graft has particular characteristics: the dishonesty often takes place at very senior levels and frequently involves groups rather than individuals. There were more than 20 people involved in Shanghai's pensions scandal, and ten in this week's media case.

Within businesses, the most likely areas for graft are the purchasing or finance departments, where staff are given kickbacks from suppliers, or the personnel department, where employees are bribed to arrange interviews or jobs. The problem has become so bad that many foreign executives claim to be “overwhelmed by the business of kickbacks,” says Stephan Rothlin of the Centre for International Business Ethics (CIBE) in Beijing.

But he says it is a mistake simply to translate or impose Western ethical standards. Although much of the corruption is driven by greed, it is also the result of a different set of beliefs. Confucianism puts loyalty to family and friends first. Then comes “face”, and finally compliance with the law. Even then, the law is seen as malleable rather than absolute. Mr Rothlin argues that foreign firms need to strike a balance between imposing their own ethical codes and understanding the local culture.

It is even harder to deal with lower-level shadiness, such as a secretary booking a flight for her boss and then getting a payment from the travel agent, or a receptionist getting paid to refer new enquiries to a rival firm. Such cases usually involve relatively small sums and are often regarded as a socially acceptable way for employees to prepare for retirement or keep up with the spending of their peers.

Dane Chamorro, the regional manager for China at Control Risks, a consultancy, says the law against commercial corruption is rarely enforced—and when it is, prosecutions usually have additional motives. He suggests that foreign firms start their operations from scratch and impose their ethical standards from day one. They also need to avoid hiring “tribes”—groups of workers from the same region, or who speak the same dialect. Such groups are known to move systematically between businesses, especially foreign ones. Training is important too, as are regular audits.

But even though there is a growing push for a clampdown, the resistance to change is strong. Fu ze ren bu zai, “the man with the key is not here”, is a common way of asking for a bribe. Alas, the man with the key to solving China's corruption problem is nowhere to be found, either.

5 comments:

Tsoi Dug said...

I strongly disagree with your assertion that Confucianism means loyalty to family and friends first, and obeying the law is optional. Of the five traditional Confucian Cardinal Relations (wu lun), that between the government and the subject comes first, before any other. So treating compliance with the law as optional is not an example of how China operates according to Confucianism, but is instead an example of how far modern China has strayed from Confucianism.

As for the secretary taking a kickback from the travel agency she books with, graft is graft and embezzlement is embezzlement, Chinese or not. Again, Confucianism is quite clear on this: honesty and trustworthiness ranks extremely high on Confucian tenets, and again the prevalence of graft is just another example of how far modern China has strayed from Confucianism.

zang said...

Nice Post
-------------
article rewrite

metin2gogo said...

air force 1 canvas low grey white 681

air force 1 canvas mid royal blue white 750

air force 1 hi black gold gum 796

air force 1 hi white obsidian blue 795

air force 1 high black grey 794

air force 1 high black white 793

air force 1 high book of ones edition 792

air force 1 high swat 791

air force 1 high white black black 790

air force 1 high white grey grey 788

air force 1 high baltimore b more edition 787

air force 1 high gore tex edition black black taxi 786

air force 1 high n2winter baroque brown net spanish moss 785

air force 1 high premium hunt edition black birch army olive orange blaze 784

air force 1 high premium baseball pack 783

air force 1 high premium futura black black sail 763

air force 1 high premium futura dark obsidian white university blue 757

air force 1 high premium 2008 mlb all star game edition white white dark obsidian 772

metin2gogo said...

air force 1 high premium bobbito edition army olive baroque brown soft grey 771

air force 1 high premium bobbito edition sanded gold sanded gold wheat 768

air force 1 high premium bobbito edition sport red white varsity royal 770

air force 1 high premium bobbito edition varsity royal white sport red 769

air force 1 high premium le 2010 nba all star game metallic silver black 759

air force 1 high sheed patent black white 782

air force 1 high supreme neutral grey white neutral grey 767

air force 1 high supreme dj clark kent nyc varsity royal black ginger 765

air force 1 high supreme eddie cruz black varsity red white 761

air force 1 high supreme futura matte silver white 764

air force 1 high supreme nitro microphone underground black black metallic gold 766

air force 1 low black anthracite stealth 464

air force 1 low black black gold 680

air force 1 low black black university blue 679

air force 1 low black black white 382

air force 1 low black black white 371

air force 1 low black gold 678

air force 1 low black white orion blue 384

metin2gogo said...

air force 1 low black black white metallic silver 361

air force 1 low black gold 676

air force 1 low dark obsidian dark obsidian 380

air force 1 low dark obsidian metallic silver white agnt 413

air force 1 low dp burgundy red earth aluminum pink 463

air force 1 low forest green white 675

air force 1 low greek 06 674

air force 1 low grey black 673

air force 1 low grey navy 672

air force 1 low grey red 671

air force 1 low harlem edition 670

air force 1 low hustlers edition 669

air force 1 low independence day edition 668

air force 1 low lux croc edition 667

air force 1 low matrix crocodile edition 666

air force 1 low metallic silver black white 421

air force 1 low mr cartoon brown pride edition 665

air force 1 low mr cartoon cinco de mayo mexico edition 664